And studiously ignoring the larger picture is not a rebuttal.
The evidence for my interpretation of events is all gathered neatly into one untidy bundle [link|http://www.kuro5hin.org|here]. No matter where you start browsing this material, the conclusion is inescapable, provided you don't stop when the pattern begins to become uncomfortably clear. Non-PC views are marginalized, even censored. Meanwhile, stupid crap about zits and booze and kind bud and how it's America's fault you can't get laid somehow manage to float to the top.
Carnage4Life is either a shill or a brainwashed idiot. And for a brainwashed idiot, he's putting a fair amount of effort into things. Granted, it's mostly cut-and-paste from standard Microsoft FUD releases, but he still has to format and spellcheck all that. Maybe it would be more to the point to say that there's a lot of effort behind what he and his kind are doing.
How about this, Karsten - instead of calling him a shill, I'll call him a brainwashed idiot. Would you prefer that? I can give him the benefit of the doubt about his motives, or about his intelligence, but not both. Take your pick.
And the submission queue is only broken in the sense that Athenian democracy was broken on the day it condemned Socrates to death. From a strictly technical point of view, it's working more or less as designed. But the fundamental concept is, well, it's not exactly ordered liberty, is it?
I'd say that Rusty's experiment in direct democracy serves as a reminder of just why it is we don't allow those under the age of eighteen to vote.
And saying that it's better than Slashdot is hardly a compelling defense. Not that I'm conceding that point. K5 is awful in a completely different way than Slashdot, thus making direct comparison meaningless.