IWETHEY v. 0.3.0 | TODO
1,095 registered users | 0 active users | 0 LpH | Statistics
Login | Create New User
IWETHEY Banner

Welcome to IWETHEY!

New TV attention span?
When I read it again last year I was amazed at how easy it was to put down at any point. There were two basic causes.

The first is that - in accord with accepted literary practice of the day - Tolkien uses the passive voice. Today people are told to use the active voice. This difference in sentence construction changes the verbal pacing and immediacy of the entire series.

The secod, and related, cause is that he told it as a series of small self-contained stories. Modern novels use the cheap trick of always having hanging story lines. Whenever you switch from one scene to another, you always have some sort of cliff-hanger.

Neither goes over well with people whose attention span has been trained by flipping channels on TV. However fast paced action will simply never touch Tolkien for the richness of mood and story. His is a world you need to visit, sit back, and enjoy for a while.

Cheers,
Ben
New Bingo: root cause with er 'prooves'! as our *ami would say..
* kinda miss Michel's passionate defenses of the indefensible - especially the Merkin brohaha :-)

Brilliant observation IMhO. It IS about the passive voice and each tale's completeness. Thus without the

remaining
.
.
.
hanging
.
.
.
mnemonic or other
.
.
.
clue (diagrammed in brain just like ^this^)
.
.
Making the above an actual!
recursive
er
meta
Magical
Thema
.
.
(he says, full of self..)
another!
recursion
into
.
.
the soon to become mere doggerel.

Anyway - I think you Nailed It!

:-\ufffd
New Agreed. well put, nothing to add
Jay O'Connor

"Going places unmapped
to do things unplanned
to people unsuspecting"
New Counterpoint - Crime and Punishment.
A wonderful pre-TV novel.

Of course, C&P was a serial which later appeared as a novel, so it's not really a fair comparison.

I don't think that TV had much to do with my lack of appreciation for The Hobbit. I enjoyed War and Peace during my HS years. One can't accuse Tolstoy of being too brief! (Trivia - According to my college Russian Lit. professor, he rewrote it something like 6 times. Voracious writer...)

But it's very likely that his writing style and my mood at the time had a lot to do with it.

Cheers,
Scott.
     short list, who HASN'T read lord of the rings - (boxley) - (50)
         Me. -NT - (Meerkat) - (1)
             You must! - (imric)
         Me too. I found "The Hobbit" tedious in HS when I tried to - (Another Scott) - (10)
             The Hobbit - (imric)
             Hobbit is very different from LotR. - (admin) - (7)
                 The Hobbit is a set up... - (ChrisR)
                 Yeah.. seems to have become fashionable of late, - (Ashton) - (4)
                     "of late"?!? This was in 1978! :-) Good points though. -NT - (Another Scott) - (3)
                         You mean.. they was a pickin at it way back then, too? -NT - (Ashton) - (2)
                             Heck yeah -- the translator who rendered it into Swedish,... - (CRConrad) - (1)
                                 Wow!.. heh, do we need any further proof then, - (Ashton)
                 Who cares if he borrowed? - (ben_tilly)
             Tolkien's writings predict that movie will fail - (ben_tilly)
         I have - to my eternal regret. - (CRConrad) - (25)
             No takers - (ChrisR) - (1)
                 Make a statement - make an exception. -NT - (CRConrad)
             Concur - (pwhysall) - (17)
                 Concur with the criticisms, nevertheless - (Ashton) - (16)
                     Or maybe he was just a senile blabbermouth. -NT - (CRConrad) - (15)
                         Since the *effect* was exactly the same as if he were... -NT - (CRConrad) - (7)
                             That is, *in effect*, what he *was* being. Wanna bet... -NT - (CRConrad) - (6)
                                 ... he *didn't* ASK for his salary to be *lowered*, by an... -NT - (CRConrad) - (5)
                                     ...amount correponding to the time (*work* time, no doubt -- -NT - (CRConrad) - (4)
                                         -- they always do this shit on work hours) he *wasn't*... -NT - (CRConrad) - (3)
                                             ...teaching ancient languages? Bet he didn't -- they... -NT - (CRConrad) - (2)
                                                 ...*never* do. So he was a senile old blabberer and *fraud*. -NT - (CRConrad) - (1)
                                                     ...all together now: lovely spam, spam, spam.... -NT - (pwhysall)
                         Yeah.. but I'll bet he had more class -NT - (Ashton) - (6)
                             ...than to try to defend the quality of his prose -NT - (Ashton) - (5)
                                 ...with quantity over -NT - (Ashton) - (4)
                                     ...umm well, you know________________________:-\ufffd - (Ashton) - (3)
                                         Um, Ash... - (ben_tilly) - (1)
                                             Damn.. another good Plan ruinted by a Fact____:[ -NT - (Ashton)
                                         He's fucking \ufffdEARNED\ufffd that senility fair & square so \ufffd-off ! -NT - (Ashton)
             hobbit great tlor the first OK rest went on an on - (boxley)
             TV attention span? - (ben_tilly) - (3)
                 Bingo: root cause with er 'prooves'! as our *ami would say.. - (Ashton)
                 Agreed. well put, nothing to add -NT - (Fearless Freep)
                 Counterpoint - Crime and Punishment. - (Another Scott)
         Me! - (warmachine)
         and Hobbit, Silmarillion, Bored Of The Rings... - (Fearless Freep) - (3)
             There actually was a book of that title - (wharris2) - (2)
                 Harvard Lampoon, IIRC - (GBert)
                 I know.. - (Fearless Freep)
         Not this week - (DonRichards)
         Yo. - (addison) - (4)
             Quiero Gilthoniel? ;-) -NT - (admin) - (3)
                 Huh? - (Fearless Freep) - (2)
                     remember "our" spanish is taught by - (boxley)
                     *sigh* - (admin)

Stop obsessing about collecting All Kinds of Stupid Crap.
197 ms