You reminded me of All Souls Night by Loreena McKennitt. I like the song so this is at least somewhat OK.

Anyways there is a variety of forms of paganism. You don't have to dance naked around a burning wicker man if you don't want to. (OTOH if that floats your boat...)

Also pagans don't have to give up a belief in God. Many pagans believe in God, but believe that God is too big to worship all at once, which is why you just worship one aspect at a time. (The variety of pagan deities all being components of one Deity.) Not all pagans believe this, but I've met plenty who do.

Cheers,
Ben