That may be the simplest 'bottom' line re the question for IT or any other group:
A Y2k-version of 'Union' (or by some catchy new name) or no ???
Who Else but an org. of peers, is apt to attain the power to question, lobby such matters as the wholesale importation of serfs? Or question the unlimited-hours work-week with beeper? Or the sometimes not even 2-weeks! 'vacation' - often expected to be taken.. a couple days at a time, at employer's convenience. Many more examples available.
Given such a smart bunch and the necessary nodding acquaintance with 'logic' - I remain mystified at the general attitude seen in now many threads re 'union' or other. And the thought.. "I'm so smart I don't need no stinkin help from Anyone" - doesn't even merit lampooning. Anyone who isn't yet aware of the net decline in workers' share of the pie, over last 20ish years - has been asleep. No other civilized country provides as little vacation, demands as many unpaid hours - as in the US. (Of course that leads into the most expen$ive med. care in history of world too - YAN thread re the Q. "why must med. care + employment be conjoined"? Insurance Cos. and the lottery..)
I suspect (merely) that a large factor in clouding mens' minds re the idea of 'representation' - is related to the massive scam and FUD exemplified by the WTO. Every action since passage of related treaties has been to further cement the rule of Int'l Corps, and their evident aim to drive down all worker reimbursement everywhere and especially within the US - regardless of any local governments and their social legislation. That last is the scary part - it's working so Well.
This goes to the heart of the conundrum you put so succinctly, if you are easily replaced then your labour is not worth much. Where is the new mechanism which demands that companies close the gap between what you make from them and they make from you. ??? Economists / MBAs appear thus far - unable to think in any new ways, as they pray for 'market corrections' and other holy relics of a more naive era.
Our Maquiladores - just across the border - ought to be evidence enough of the trend and the ease with which environmental and human rights considerations are easily laterally arabesqued, often via overt bribery.
So.. do you guys still think in 2002, you can escape the epithet, if we don't all hang together, assuredly we shall all hang. Separately. ?
Just Wondering (still)
Ashton