Not too shabby - Medieval Mayhem's #2 behind Lady Bug. Lady Bug's [link|http://www.atariage.com/store/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=21_85|#4 in the bestsellers](right hand column) for Atari Age. It's been available 7 months vs Medieval Mayhem's 3 months.
Nice comments too:
128 bytes
Lady Bug is my favorite singleplayer game of the year, and Medieval Mayhem is my favorite multiplayer game of the year, and is the best homebrew paddle game to date (surpassing my previous favorite, Marble Craze).
johnnywc (author of Lady Bug)
Medieval Mayhem is awesome - almost hard to believe it's running on a 2600. I wish I was able to play the game with my 3 brothers like with Warlords & the good ol' days (hopefully next Christmas).
There's also [link|http://www.atariage.com/store/index.php?main_page=product_reviews&cPath=21_85_24&products_id=842&number_of_uploads=0|1 review] online so far - 5 joysticks out of 5. Not a very in-depth review, but nice nonetheless :-)
Atari Times [link|http://ataritimes.com/rankings.php?System=2600|2600 Game Rankings] currently has Medieval Mayhem at #2 as well. It has 5 votes averaging 98%; just behind Ladybug with 9 votes, also averaging 98%.