So?

Post #279,197 by Seamus 3/22/07 10:11:14 AM 3/22/07 10:11:34 AM Reply	So? So what if it is his direct staff, what they want to question his direct staff about doesn't seem to fall under the category of exec privilege. Or are you now claiming that exec privilege covers his direct staff regardless of the topic? Which is way out there. Unless I am mistaken, what can be claimed under exec privilege is the activities of the white house, not the staff. Seamus Edited by Seamus March 22, 2007, 10:11:34 AM EDT So? So what if it is his direct staff, what they want to question his direct staff about doesn't seem to fall under the category of exec privilege. Or are you now claiming that exec privilege covers his direct staff regardless of the topic? Which is way out there. Unless I am mistaken, what can be claimed under exec privlege is the activities of the white house, not the staff. Seamus Collapse All History
Post #279,200 by bepatient 3/22/07 10:14:43 AM Reply	So Rove is not White House staff now? Too much of today's music is fashionable crap dressed as artistry._{Adrian Belew}
Post #279,201 by Seamus 3/22/07 10:19:58 AM Reply	You missed my point that exec privilege covers activities not people. If the activity is covered by exec privilege, then they can claim they don't have to testify. Even President Clinton didn't claim exec privilege exempted him from testifying, though he did negotiate the specifics of how he testified. Seamus
Post #279,203 by boxley 3/22/07 10:39:59 AM Reply	a link [link\|http://www.cnn.com/ALLPOLITICS/1998/05/05/executive.privilege/\|http://www.cnn.com/A...cutive.privilege/] In a setback for President Bill Clinton, a federal judge has ruled that White House aides may not claim executive privilege before the Whitewater grand jury looking into sex-and-perjury allegations against the president. Unless the White House appeals and wins, the decision means White House aides Sidney Blumenthal and Bruce Lindsey will have to appear before the grand jury and answer its questions. Lindsey is a lawyer and longtime friend of the president; Blumenthal was a sympathetic journalist before he joined the White House as a communications advisor. because Clinton lost this case he knew claiming executive privilege would not keep him from testifying. thanx, bill Any opinions expressed by me are mine alone, posted from my home computer, on my own time as a free american and do not reflect the opinions of any person or company that I have had professional relations with in the past 51 years. meep reach me at [link\|mailto:bill.oxley@cox.net\|mailto:bill.oxley@cox.net]
Post #279,211 by Seamus 3/22/07 12:48:48 PM Reply	That is the why he chose to negotiate The point was that Bush's direct staff is not exempt for testifying if exec privilege doesn't apply, assuming there is evidence they are involved. If it does apply, then any testimony is voluntary regardless of their position on the white house org chart. The fact that Rove was Bush's deputy chief staff at the time the emails were written is irrelevant. Seamus

Welcome to IWETHEY!