1. Why did he save a severed finger? Odd that he didnt seek medical attention to try to get the finger reattached. If he had, I'm sure the doc wouldnt let him walk out with with the finger in a baggie.
2. The finger was said to have a manicured, female-looking nail when it was found in the chili. Did the man routinely manicure his nails or did he pretty it up after it was severed? Either choice is equally disturbing.
I also heard that the woman and the nine-fingered man may have been having an affair. The plot thickens.......