IWETHEY v. 0.3.0 | TODO
1,095 registered users | 0 active users | 0 LpH | Statistics
Login | Create New User
IWETHEY Banner

Welcome to IWETHEY!

New Analogy doesn't hold
An example would be if the NYPD decided to bomb a restaraunt because a known mob boss was eating there.

Is this mob boss trying to drive the Jews out of by NY by force?

Is this mob boss organizing suicide bombers to carry out attacks in major NY institutions? And an increasing number of those bombers are teenagers and may be younger? (If the Pals view their children as expendable combatants, why should we shed a tear? Besides, how many potential suicide bomber lives will be spared by cutting the heads off of Hamas, Islamic Jhihad, etc. before they can organize the next wave of bombings?)

Is this restaurant in a borough where the population supports the mob and just about every male over 12 in the area has a Kalashnikov and wouldn't hesitate to fire it on a cop (echos of Black Hawk Down here!).

If these conditions were true, do you think we would be treating this as a simple police operation? Kind of hard to recite the Miranda Rights while RPG's are exploding around you.
Ray
New It does hold.
Is this mob boss trying to drive the Jews out of by NY by force?
He's driving out other criminal organizations.

Is this mob boss organizing suicide bombers to carry out attacks in major NY institutions?
He's ordering the deaths of others.

And an increasing number of those bombers are teenagers and may be younger?
Why does the age matter?

(If the Pals view their children as expendable combatants, why should we shed a tear? Besides, how many potential suicide bomber lives will be spared by cutting the heads off of Hamas, Islamic Jhihad, etc. before they can organize the next wave of bombings?)
Okay, every Palestinian in Gaza has the exact same views as every other Palestinian in Gaza. Right?

Wrong. What ONE organization views children as has ZERO relevence to how OTHER people view children and EVEN LESS RELEVENCE to how WE should treat children.

Is this restaurant in a borough where the population supports the mob and just about every male over 12 in the area has a Kalashnikov and wouldn't hesitate to fire it on a cop (echos of Black Hawk Down here!).
Are you saying that in such a circumstance you would agree with the missle strike? There are neighborhoods in the US where gang activity is similar to what you describe.

Yet we don't do military strikes against their leaders.

If these conditions were true, do you think we would be treating this as a simple police operation? Kind of hard to recite the Miranda Rights while RPG's are exploding around you.
Nice visual. But wouldn't the RPG's also kill the leader who was being detained?

The analogy is correct. A person who is a leader of a criminal organization that orders the deaths of innocents is in a public building.

The age of the people doing the killing does not matter.

Whether they are suicides or not does not matter.

What his goals are do not matter.

Whether he has lots of friendlies around him does not matter.

Do we launch an attack that we KNOW will kill innocents in the surrounding area just so we can kill him?

The end does not justify the means.
     Hamas leader killed, children killed too - (marlowe) - (38)
         This is to be condemned by all sides - (boxley) - (1)
             Israel is all in knots over it. - (Arkadiy)
         Residential building, after midnight. - (Brandioch) - (6)
             They should be using the SAS Model that the Brits used in NI - (boxley)
             Murican as apple pie IF... - (Ashton) - (4)
                 Yup. - (Brandioch) - (3)
                     "collateral damage" - this ugly and premeditated event - (Ashton)
                     Nit - (boxley) - (1)
                         When did that ever stop us or our allies? - (Brandioch)
         2 reactions - (wharris2) - (14)
             Small children are by definition innocent. - (marlowe) - (13)
                 Never had any kids, did you? - (orion) - (8)
                     Re: Never had any kids, did you? - (wharris2) - (1)
                         I am a father of twins, - (Arkadiy)
                     Better nip that in the bud. - (marlowe) - (5)
                         How do I get his respect? - (orion) - (4)
                             (scratch) - (Andrew Grygus)
                             Re: How do I get his respect? - (Arkadiy) - (2)
                                 Wise words. - (Ashton)
                                 Simplicity works well - (Silverlock)
                 Bull - (Andrew Grygus) - (3)
                     Bull indeed. - (Arkadiy) - (2)
                         Nostalgia . . - (Andrew Grygus) - (1)
                             Yep - (Arkadiy)
         Re: Children Killed ? - (dmarker2) - (9)
             But that's the problem. - (Brandioch) - (8)
                 One major difference - (screamer)
                 The target matters - (mhuber) - (6)
                     That's how it always is. - (Brandioch) - (5)
                         Q for you - (rsf) - (3)
                             No. - (Brandioch) - (2)
                                 Analogy doesn't hold - (rsf) - (1)
                                     It does hold. - (Brandioch)
                         Problem. - (wharris2)
         Time for the ICC to step in? - (ChrisR) - (3)
             Results - (wharris2) - (1)
                 Re: Kaddafi (Qadaffi, etc:) - (dmarker2)
             How can the ICC put sharon in the doc without putting arafat - (boxley)

For office use only.
56 ms