The Kushners reportedly bought Lot 4 of the village, which comprises just 41 residential lots. The property was listed at $31.8 million by singer-songwriter and longtime Indian Creek resident Julio Iglesias in January. Though the lot is currently empty, it offers 80,000 square feet of space on which to construct a coastal estate, including 200 feet of private waterfront on Biscayne Bay.

Indian Creek is colloquially referred to as the Billionaire Bunker due to a high-powered roster of residents that includes Iglesias, Adriana Lima, billionaire Carl Icahn, and Dutch businessman Geert-Jan Bakker, who purchased a property there from Beyoncé and Jay-Z in 2010. The island is gated and guarded by its own police force and 24/7 armed boat patrol, and also boasts its own private country club and golf course.