To start off with I took 2 dollar store organization bins, about a square foot each.
I drilled holes on the bottom of 1, filled it with 6 filter bags full of activated charcoal and ammonia neutralizer, and 2 layers of fish tank filter material.
The filter material, charcoal, and bags cost about $40.
I drilled a bunch of holes in the side of another. I places the filter box on top of the other, and placed a pump (had hanging around, previous project) in the pond, pushing water through a 1/2 inch tube to the top box, and anchored it down.
It worked, but was ugly.
Last night I ripped it apart. I took the bags of filter material and layed them into the channels of the current large fake rock waterfall. It is about 3 feet high and 4 feet wide, with 4 levels. I placed the hose on the top, and buried everything in real rocks and fake frogs and turtles. I forced the water flow to go from bag to bag, when done going through multiple bags of charcoal that are hardly seen.
Much happier now.
I told my neighbor he can deliver the rest of the fish. I'm going to teach them that tapping the rock leads to feeding, which in turn hopefully gives me a pavlov's feeding reponse. I'd also like to teach them to be hand fed.
He said you can't kill them if you try. In winter, the pond can freeze solid. When it thaws, they will start swimming again. I'll toss a heater in it anyway.
It is amazing as the people walk by. Sure, standard kid / family hang out, but the real fun comes from the tough guys getting all melty from the pretty fish.