the first 2 were on the "employee suggestions" shelf. After seeing that trailer I decided to pick them up next time I was over there, and last night was the next time. I've read the first one so far - it was hilarious.

The trailers (there's 2 available at Apple) show a definite feel for the source material. I liked Michael Cera's character in Arrested Development and think he's a very good fit for Scott Pilgrim.
http://trailers.appl...ilgrimvstheworld/

Test screenings look promising. Kevin Smith really liked it:
http://www.slashfilm...tf-just-hit-them/

That movie is great. It’s spellbinding and nobody is going to understand what the fuck just hit them. I would be hard pressed to say,”he’s bringing a comic book to life!” but he is bringing a comic book to life. If you’ve ever seen Scott Pilgrim, he did a fucking damn fine job of taking essentially an anime looking book and putting it into the real world while keeping everything about that book that’s kind of cool and what pops.

There's links to other reviews in the article, all positive.