Compared with the devastation in and nearby USSR..
our completely bio-heedless behavior of decades ... still sucks.
Of course, both strategies were based upon Keeping The / Our People Safe.
By annihilating The Other People. And if both had played-out the MAD-blueprint, a goodly share of all living things on the planet would have disappeared in the short-run and long-term.
Because We're Right, etc.
If there were a Higher Authority, it never would have turned over a beautiful blue/green planet to such apes; Bonobos..? maybe: they're happy to sit around grooming and screwing and they don't eat each other, like homo-sap and the other 98%-homo-sap relatives.
Dunno about you, but the more I learn of human 'history', especially matters later uncovered after the victors rewrote the various incidents -- the more I believe that we are congenitally clinically-insane. The few exceptional folks' sane contributions merely make The Mob appear even worse.
(I used to pore through the various 'incidents' in the nicely stocked LBL library.. like the SL-1 in Idaho, whose operators managed to pull out ("up") enough control rods that, when it blew: two or more were pinned to the ceiling via some other rods + debris. Buried in lead-lined caskets, those.)
Then 'They' == We crucified Oppenheimer / not a team-member, as Teller pushed for The Super (while Ulam did all the heavy-math lifting.) WE could have evaded the arms race from before the outset (wherein >We< pushed for MIRVS, forcing the Russians to counter, after which -- well we know what happened.)
I wrote to Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists during the Cheney Shogunate, asking if The Clock could /should be moved forward for other than technological gamesmanship -- like say, the effects of an unstable Head-of-State? and all that might follow from such a one in control of strategic weapons.. They published it. Oh well.
(I'd reset to 2 min < Midnight, right now. But that's just me, and I've only studied nukes since about age 14, so what do I know. But we know what Oppenheimer Knew. And it didn't matter then, either.
(And some people think that Opera plots are silly. Hah ... then there's Dr. Atomic.)
oTyp
Edited by
Ashton
Jan. 25, 2010, 05:30:20 AM EST