IWETHEY v. 0.3.0 | TODO
1,095 registered users | 0 active users | 0 LpH | Statistics
Login | Create New User
IWETHEY Banner

Welcome to IWETHEY!

New Kubuntu 9.04 with KDE 4.x is broken on my T41.
In my experience, it isn't worth messing with. On my T41:

1) Ungodly slow. Even when tweaking the video driver settings. 8.04 was much faster.
2) Pokey wireless network transfers, when you're able to connect. WICD works pretty well, but it doesn't fix all the problems.
3) KUpdateManager (or whatever it's called) is ungodly uninformative. It has 5 updates marked as "blocked" but tells me nothing about them. Trying to update the repository lists or changing the update server location causes Python 2.6 to crash before the list finishes (it hangs at 103 of 113). There's no clear way to run Synaptic instead. It seems impossible to do a full update successfully, at least with a GUI.
4) There's no clear way to install KDE 3.x instead.
5) Konqueror is extremely unresponsive with 5 tabs open and its memory consumption increases for no apparent reason. Firefox is more stable, but is still slow and a RAM hog.
6) 200 MB of swap is being used with 1 GB of RAM free, for no apparent reason.
7) Something seems to be grabbing 100% of the CPU and making the CPU temperature rise excessively, but it's not clear in the process list. Killing Konqueror takes care of most of the problem and unpins the CPU.

Etc.

I'm trying to install Gnome on it at the moment. Perhaps that will make it bearable before I transfer everything important off it to try Debian. I might also try Mepis again since that usually seemed to run well on it (and it is still on KDE 3.x).

Cheers,
Scott.
New Using Gnome is *much* better, at least for browsing...
New Have you tried booting with acpi=off?
You'll lose power management, deck lid switch, etc. but this should isolate any related issues that can cause the slowdown and CPU grab. There are some flaky things going on with ACPI in the recent kernel releases. Among other things, excessive timer interrupts can eat the CPU, which would not show in the process list.

I've been digging into this for the last few weeks because Debian Lenny is very hard to get going on my work HP 6515b with ACPI enabled (both x86 and amd64 flavors). I finally got things halfway stable booting with pci=noacpi.

I suspect the wireless issue may also be kernel related. So far, I've been unable to get any wireless going on the 6515b (includes the onboard Broadcom 4311, an Atheros Cardbus card, and a stone age ADM8211 802.11b only card and using all drivers I could get my hands on.) The drivers load, but an occasional spurt of time-out errors in the dmesg log is all that happens.
New Very interesting.
No, I haven't tried the ACPI switch yet. I'll see if I can do that when I return to it more intensively. I haven't depended on the power management stuff working in any of my Linux installs - I just leave the intensity turned down with the lid propped open, and stand it up on its leading edge, propped up out of the way... :-/

I suspect you're right on several counts, but the system is much better with the default Gnome install. I noticed in my brief poking around that Gnome has many of the fancy GUI enhancements turned off, while I think a lot of them were turned on with KDE 4.x. I don't know enough about either of them to do much tuning yet....

The wireless still seems a little flaky, taking several minutes to connect to my WAP, and DNSes seem to be lost for no apparent reason for a minute at a time, but it is working.

Thanks very much for your comments, especially on the Debian caveats. Given all of that, and since the T41 is mainly just for playing around during commercials while I watch TV, I'll look around a little but won't assume that simply a new Linux distro install will fix it. I'll probably just live with it until I have a more pressing need.

I'll report back if I find out anything more that might be useful to you or others.

Thanks again.

Cheers,
Scott.
New Have to do that to get the CD/DVD player to work
So I can have the lid switch work and have it shut down correctly, or I can play/burn optical media, but not both at the same time.
--

Drew
     Kubuntu 9.04 with KDE 4.x is broken on my T41. - (Another Scott) - (4)
         Using Gnome is *much* better, at least for browsing... -NT - (Another Scott)
         Have you tried booting with acpi=off? - (scoenye) - (2)
             Very interesting. - (Another Scott)
             Have to do that to get the CD/DVD player to work - (drook)

So does a burning bus.
104 ms