I like complex films - honestly, the only Lord of the Rings film that I thought was GOOD was the first one, and that was only after the extended edition came out. Ian McKellen was robbed IMO - he should have gotten at least a nod for best supporting actor. The redeeming part in TTT was Gollum, who was also robbed. RotK was a farce, and the nominations and awards for that one really belonged to the first one.
I can't watch a film any more without dissecting it. It is driving me up the wall, honestly, because I can't watch something to numb my brain any more, unless it catches me offguard and makes me laugh.