But yeah, don't know if it really deserved a place on the list - after all is was pretty much a 'me-too' game.

there's never going to be a list like this that everyone agrees with. Maybe that's why newspapers and magazines keep doing them. Incites discussion, leads to sales...

Haven't played StarFlight or Fallout/Wasteland. Can't think, off the top of my head, of any games that should be on the list. Maybe The Settlers, just because it one of those games that for great stretched of time I simply couldn't put down.