IWETHEY v. 0.3.0 | TODO
1,095 registered users | 0 active users | 0 LpH | Statistics
Login | Create New User
IWETHEY Banner

Welcome to IWETHEY!

New See what it took for the Wiccans
That was a 10 year ordeal where the VA basically acted as if they had their fingers in their ears, going "Lalalala - I can't hear you!!". But it does seem to have moved things onto a faster track.
New I'm a little more sympathetic to
..."established" religions of ancient provenance because these at least took hold originally among largely illiterate populations and in cultures where "supernatural" was the default explanation for any phenomenon not readily understood, and present-day adherents are working from a substrate of scores of generations of culture and belief. I have less patience with post-Enlightenment growths such as Mormonism, Scientology, Wicca. The founders of the first two were outright frauds, and of the third, the most charitable take on the man who promugated its silly doctrines is that he was a deluded crank.

cordially,
New now, now I have never had a wiccan strive to get in my wallet
always look out for number one and don't step in number two
New Gardner was not the worst of his time.
Sure, as far as Wicca goes, he pulled together where he could and invented where he could not. But most Wiccans pick and choose, anyway, just like Gardner did.

However, the grandest ire is reserved for Margaret Murray who invented reams of history that just don't exist, some of which Gardner built on.

Wade.
New You are of course correct about Mormonism and Scientology, but your incredulity...
...at the Hammer of Thor feels weird, even slightly annoying. Asatro is a prefectly normal religion; everybody in the North used to believe it until those evil Jihadists from the South spread their perfidious lies here. (And in my name, to boot!)

Also, while you may know more than I about the exact composition of modern-day Wicca, I was under the impression that on the whole, it is pretty much like Asatro, an attempted revival of pre-Me religions, only more Celtic than North-Germanic. OK, perhaps with a little more general-pantheistic Nature worship and "New Age" mumbo-jumbo thrown in (though I think many current Asa worshippers also lean in those directions?), but on the whole for most practitioners a more-or-less sincere belief system -- as opposed to Pastafarianism and that Jedi "religion", which also feels more "for fun" to me (although I think I saw an article on it being in some sense "officially recognised" [perhaps in Oz?] even before the CFSM NZ wedding article linked here).

And I certainly don't get the same vibe of "organised scam from the start and from the top down" as Scientology, either from Asatro or Wicca; does anyone here?
--
Christian R. Conrad
Same old username (as above), but now on iki.fi

(Yeah, yeah, it redirects to the same old GMail... But just in case I ever want to change.)
New Wicca, Druidism etc.
Wicca and Druidism had to be made up from scratch, as there was just about zero reliable historical anything.

With Wicca, Gardner's claim to have been initiated by a secret coven of Celtic witches, is, of course, like all such claims (golden tablets, etc), pure bullshit. That it is all made from whole cloth doesn't bother me, it serves the people practicing it, and it's pretty much harmless. Wicca has split into "British Traditional" (Gardnarian) and sects that were not trained in the Gardnarian tradition, primarily in North America and Continental Europe. This is fine - it's a developing philosophy and some of the bullshit is being thrown away. Of course, there's Dianic Wicca, which accepts only naturally born lesbians and recognizes only a goddesses, and other splinter groups - pretty much harmless because of very limited membership. There are plenty of other covens for the rejected.

Contemporary Druidism started out with just about no reliable information except that the Druids believed in reincarnation and had some to do with mistletoe. Everything else is questionable due to having been written by their enemies, and some just by hearsay. It started out monotheistic, based of Freemasonry, but evolved rapidly in the 20th century as archaeologists found more information on Celtic culture. It is now polytheistic and nature based with a strong environmental bent. Again, I don't see a problem - it serves its practitioners and is harmless. Like Wicca, it's highly decentralized. Of course, they like to have events at Stonehenge, which was built 2000 years before the first Druid by a people we know nothing about except they were very good at astronomical mathematics and at moving rocks.

Reconstruction is much easier in places like Lithuania and Abkhazia where much was preserved, and even Russia and Ukraine. The largest Pagan temple in the US is Russian. Ossetia is a good reference for reconstructing Pagan traditions, because 30% of its people still hold to an unbroken tradition, having rejected both Christianity and Islam.

The main problem is in Germany, where violent neo-Nazi groups are disguising themselves as Heathen churches.
New Yeah, IIUC Nordic Neo-Nazis are also big on the Asatro. Sigh...
New LRPD: "Why, that looks so dangerous - I'm sure I'll learn something wonderful!"
Regards,
-scott
Welcome to Rivendell, Mr. Anderson.
     War on religious freedom continues apace - (rcareaga) - (19)
         It's taught in UU faith classes - (malraux)
         That's a tricky one - (drook) - (16)
             "A tough line to walk" - (rcareaga) - (15)
                 Amazing list - (drook) - (3)
                     copyright issues - (rcareaga)
                     With those selections, it should be longer. - (static)
                     #50 - (scoenye)
                 My guess is it's just a matter of time. - (Another Scott) - (10)
                     See what it took for the Wiccans - (scoenye) - (7)
                         I'm a little more sympathetic to - (rcareaga) - (6)
                             now, now I have never had a wiccan strive to get in my wallet -NT - (boxley)
                             Gardner was not the worst of his time. - (static)
                             You are of course correct about Mormonism and Scientology, but your incredulity... - (CRConrad) - (3)
                                 Wicca, Druidism etc. - (Andrew Grygus) - (2)
                                     Yeah, IIUC Nordic Neo-Nazis are also big on the Asatro. Sigh... -NT - (CRConrad)
                                     LRPD: "Why, that looks so dangerous - I'm sure I'll learn something wonderful!" -NT - (malraux)
                     Like smoke breaks for nonsmokers -NT - (drook) - (1)
                         Yup. -NT - (Another Scott)
         NZ gives them the proper respect. - (a6l6e6x)

Go now (but sparingly) and keepeth this monstrous creation from leaving ruts in My green fields and tundras; aimeth thine albatross within the scriptured dinosaur tracks provided by Mammon.
174 ms